Animation

What sort of future do you want?

Where is animation heading, and what sort of future do you want to see?

Over the past couple of weeks there have been a wave of announcements which have left me thinking a lot about the direction that animation is heading, and the sort of future which is currently being built.

This article is a long one but, I believe, an important one.

‍

Disney

Disney have long been regarded as one of the benchmarks for high quality animation, but their recent actions suggest a significant departure from that legacy.

Over the past year, they have eliminated well over a thousand roles, with thousands more employees expected to lose their jobs in the near future. This comes at a time when the company is not struggling financially, but is simply choosing to reinvest in AI technology.

After hiring the former CEO of controversial AI chatbot Character.AI as their new Chief Technology Officer, that company declared bankruptcy within days. Disney then acquired their assets at a discounted price and committed to spending $180 million over three years to hire 66 of it’s former employees.

They have now also announced a multi-year deal in which Adobe will act as their official “AI Innovation Partner”. Together, they are planning to train AI models on their IP to “generate commercially safe and production-ready outputs.”

‍

Ed Cutmull

On top of the recent announcements from Disney, I watched a video in which Dr Ed Cutmull, co-founder of Pixar, spoke with the CEO of the Generative AI company Higgsfield.

Whilst I can absolutely understand Catmull’s interest in the technology as a computer scientist, I was still extremely disappointed to see him associating with such a company, and therefore legitimising them.

Higgsfield are a company which has grown massively in a very short time frame by utilising a range of unpleasant tactics, as detailed in this Forbes article:

Racist Videos And Payment Problems: The Dark Side Of This AI Startup’s Super-Fast Growth

It’s not that the technology is not impressive. What it can already do is far beyond what most people would have imagined a few years ago, and I think that Catmull made very valid points about the potential future trajectory of such tools, especially given the ridiculous amounts of money currently being invested in them. The problem is, his apparent support completely overlooks the way that such tools, and companies, are able to function in the first place.

‍

The problems with Gen AI

Whilst Disney’s deal with Adobe aims to train on their own IP, the Gen AI tools offered by Higgsfield, and others, have been trained upon vast quantities of artists’ creations without consent, credit, or compensation.

Whilst these AI companies claim a defence of “fair use”, when companies are large enough to threaten significant legal action against them, they quickly make deals to licence the material they are using. For everyone else, they simply continue taking what they want.

In addition, these tools come with significant environmental and societal downsides. People are loosing their livelihoods to Gen AI tools trained upon their own work. They are then being encouraged to switch to using these same tools which, rather than distributing wealth throughout the creative economy, consolidate all of that within a handful of major tech giants.

‍

It’s not about a fear of new technology

New technologies have always been used to push animation forward, from the introduction of sound and colour, through the use of the multiplane camera, to digital technologies, and computer graphics. All of these were designed to get around limitations and improve the films which people were able to create.

Gen AI is not a technology which is claiming to push the artform forwards. Instead, it simply offers the potential to create videos which look like animation (but have not been animated), faster, and with fewer people.

This speed is valued by large studios, desperate to pump out a regular stream of “content”, but it comes with a range of significant downsides.

‍

The death of creativity?

Higgsfield used their interview with Ed Catmull to draw parallels between the early days of computer animation, something which Catmull played an instrumental part in, and the current development of Generative AI tools.

The key difference, however, is that computer graphics enabled the creation of entirely new styles of animation and imagery, whilst Gen AI simply copies what has come before.

Gen AI tools are very good at re-mixing the elements they’ve been trained upon but, if everything created in the future is entirely dependent upon what has come before, where do new leaps in creativity come from?

‍

Where do we go from here?

With Disney heavily pushing into the AI space, and the apparent endorsement of Higgsfield, and Gen AI filmmaking as an inevitable future, by one of the founders of Pixar and computer graphics itself, I was left feeling somewhat depressed for the future of animation.

Then I went to watch Wildwood.

‍

Wildwood

Laika’s latest stop-motion film, Wildwood, is the complete opposite of everything I’ve previously mentioned.

With Wildwood, Laika have focussed on craft and quality rather than speed, pushing the limits of what is possible with stop-motion animation to an entirely new height. It is a film which has been in development for sixteen years, and active production for the last six.

What’s notable is that, far from rejecting new technology, Laika embrace it wholeheartedly. Their puppet armatures are bespoke masterpieces of miniature engineering, designed to provide the finest possible control to their animators. They then make use of 3D computer animation for background elements, set extensions, and combined with 3D printing, for all of the facial animation.

For all of their advances in stop-motion animation, a film of the the scope of Wildwood simply wouldn’t be possible without this hybrid approach.

What Wildwood Director, and Laika CEO, Travis Knight is very clear about, however, is his stance on Generative AI. In one of his many interviews promoting the film he stated:

“Ai is antithetical to everything that we stand for at Laika, because at Laika, at the centre of everything we do is the artist. Stop motion wears it’s humanity openly, and AI has no humanity. So it’s one of these things where it really is an amazing technology, but it’s soulless. And telling stories, making art, it’s all about imbuing what you’re doing with soul.”

‍

Aside from the rise of AI, we live in a time when film studios are merging and fewer creative risks are being taken. Travis Knight has described making a stop-motion film in this modern era as a “quiet act of rebellion”.

If you get the chance, I encourage you to go and watch Wildwood on the biggest screen possible. It’s a remarkable film and, by supporting “acts of rebellion” like this, you’ll be voting for a future in which genuine art, and creativity, is still allowed to thrive.

‍

Inbetweens

Other articles you might enjoy: